Skip to main content

Questions about nuclear fuel....

Last week, the Sustainable Development Commission, an UK government advisory panel, came out strongly against nuclear energy. Its main arguments were that doubling nuclear capacity would have only little effect on carbon emissions and that disadvantages outweigh the advantages.

It had listed five disadvantages,
** No long-term solutions for the storage of nuclear waste are yet available, says the SDC, and storage presents clear safety issues
** The economics of nuclear new-build are highly uncertain, according to the report
** Nuclear would lock the UK into a centralised energy distribution system for the next 50 years when more flexible distribution options are becoming available
** The report claims that nuclear would undermine the drive for greater energy efficiency
** If the UK brings forward a new nuclear programme, it becomes more difficult to deny other countries the same technology, the SDC claims

I think these disadvantages need to be raised before the Government of India as it decides to go for full fledged nuclear energy expansion (according to one report, it aims to have 25% of total energy generation through nuclear energy). Has the government thought about these issues. As in the medium to long term, the distribution system is set to be privatised or corporatised in the case of state electricity boards, how would more focus on nuclear energy affect the reforms? What is the expected cost of generating nuclear energy with availability of new technologies?? Will it be competitive?


Saumitra said…
John, you have to look at the problems with the number one electricity generator in the US --- coal. Coal has severe problems. This months National Geographic Magazine points out several coal related issues. Check out this small excerpt on problems with coal at

Also there is a second article excerpt on Strip Mining of Mountains to find coal in America.

50% of the US Electricity Generation comes from Coal, but it causes 83% of all American Carbon Dioxide Emissions. Coal mining companies are now using a process called Strip-Mining to get the maximum amount of coal from a mountain. Essentially the process blows up a large portion of the mountain. Hence, a large portion of America's Appalation Mountain Range is disappearing. Furthermore, the coal dust and the pollution from these mines that run into the main water supplies are creating birth-defects and major health problems. I am not trying to debunk your views, but I think people forget about the drawbacks of coal--the main source of energy. I forgot about the problems of coal as well, but my friend who studied environmental economics taught me about the problems with coal a fews weeks before I found this issuse of National Geographic. The magazine calls this problem, "The Coal Paradox: We can't live without it. But can we survive with it?" Check it out.

Popular posts from this blog

Being hopeless....

Three months back when my mom was visiting me, she experience heart palpitations for two consecutive nights. Worried I called my cardiologist friend who asked us to visit him in the government hospital on that day as it was a non-OPD (out patients day) duty for him. Apparently non-OPD days are less crowded. As we sat waiting, we saw many worried parents bringing their just born babies to treat serious heart problems. What struck me were the faces of these parents - a feeling of hopelessness. This was their last hope to treat their infants in a state-run hospital as they don't  have money to take them elsewhere.

Fortunately, the staff at this government hospital were treating patients sympathetically. I hoped the patients would have got the best of treatment available. In comparison, patients were treated as cattle herds at the All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS), India's premier hospital. To get an cardio OPD appointment, you will have stand in the line from 5 PM …

Happiness, street vendors, and negotiations......

Few days back I was watching a documentary series, "India's Frontier Trains". The three-part series was on trains connecting India with its neighbours - Bangladesh, Pakistan and Nepal. Yes, there is a train connection between India and Nepal, and that train is the only functioning train for the whole of Nepal.

In the episode on the train between India and Bangladesh, the program documented a life of a chocolate seller inside the train. He boards the train in the Bangladesh side of the route. A sole bread winner for a family of four, he earns by selling chocolates in the train.

He faces a perennial problem: because of hot weather conditions, his chocolates melt. In those hot days, his earnings are meager. A basic cooling device like this costs seventeen pounds and he couldn't afford that.

What moved me was the insensitive nature of some passengers in haggling with this struggling chocolate seller. They would force down the price by 10 pence or more (which is more tha…

With no choice and voice….

Last Sunday I took a friend of mine to the emergency gynecology ward in one of Delhi's private mission hospitals. It was a lean day with not much of activity and I was chatting with my friend's husband, it was then I noticed a pregnant women walking in along with two of her relations. They have been referred to this hospital by the nearby government hospital as the private hospital would take better care of her. The reason: the estimated weight of the baby she was carrying was grossly under-weight, measuring only 1.2 kgs even after nine months of pregnancy. She was in great discomfort as her membrane broke, and sat next to me in a wooden bench.
In the meantime, I saw a lady doctor talking angrily out of frustration with relations of this pregnant lady, including her husband. With little knowledge of Hindi, I couldn't follow the conversation. Another friend had come by this time, and also a senior doctor was summoned by the lady doctor who first talked to pregnant lady'…